TEST TEST TEST
Products
The Surprising Senate Votes in the Bipartisan Permitting Bill

This is Heatmap Daily, a weekday digest written by our executive editor. Subscribe here.
The Senate will vote tonight on amendments to the permitting reform bill, officially known as the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act.
It will then vote on the bill itself — which only needs a bare majority to pass. The House of Representatives will then take up the bill.
The permitting bill, in other words, has survived that peculiar phase of Senate process where legislation requires more than 60 votes to pass. (That magic number isn’t due to anything in the Constitution, but because Senate procedure technically allows unlimited and silent “debate” on a measure, and it takes a two-thirds majority to end that “debate.” Changing this is what people mean when they talk about “ending the filibuster.”)
All of this is to say that the bill’s Senate coalition might be as large now as it has ever been. Senators have now taken a handful of these 60-vote-threshold cloture votes on BAAJA, and we can see who voted for the measure last week at the beginning of the debate and who had peeled off by the end.
As we await final votes on the amendments and the bill itself, here’s some brief game-time analysis:
Almost every Republican voted yes. Since the first cloture vote on November 9, almost everyone in the Senate GOP caucus has voted in favor of the bill. Mike Rounds, the junior senator from South Dakota, is the only Republican to vote no in every roll call. Missouri’s Josh Hawley, who opposes the bill’s transmission provisions, started out voting yes but voted no today.
Democrats have eroded. Twenty-five Democratic senators (or those who caucus with them) have voted against the bill at every ballot. They include Senators Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, Ed Markey, and Ron Wyden.
But some Democrats who started off supporting the bill peeled off as the politics have developed or as they jockey to add amendments or shape the bill during its final process. Jon Ossoff voted yes on the initial cloture vote, but voted no on its final cloture vote today. The bill contains Cathy Cortez Masto’s mining measure, and she voted yes on it for its first cloture vote, but no today. Gary Peters of Michigan, Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, Andy Kim of New Jersey also voted no today.
There’s a surprising amount of same-state splits. BAAJA’s politics have been quite geographic at times — as Julian NoiseCat observed on Shift Key, Western senators with close tribal ties have clearly approached the law differently than those from the East Coast or Midwest — but it’s also revealed surprising splits in the Democratic caucus that don’t necessarily come down to ideology or location. Senator Raphael Warnock of Georgia voted yes on every cloture vote, for instance, but Senator Jon Ossoff started out yes and then switched to no. Senator Martin Heinrich of New Mexico helped write the bill, but his same-state colleague Senator Ben Ray Lujan voted against cloture. Arizona’s Mark Kelly is a no, but Ruben Gallego is a yes. Cory Booker in New Jersey is a yes, but his colleague Andy Kim started out yes … and then became a no.
Among Democrats, there’s something of a “new school” vs “old school” divide on how to fight climate change. I thought it was notable that Senator Brian Schatz of Hawaii, a self-described climate hawk, has evidently signaled he will vote yes on final passage, according to Josh Siegel of Punchbowl. Schatz is part of the group that once called themselves “the three climateers,” a troika of Democratic senators who worked on climate change and decarbonization through the bad old days of the 2010s. The other two members of that group? Senators Martin Heinrich and Sheldon Whitehouse, who led the Democratic side of the negotiations over this bill.
Whitehouse and Heinrich argue that this bill — because it will speed up permitting, especially for transmission lines, and put clean energy to something closer to an even footing with fossil fuels — is good for the climate. They also argue that it will allow future climate policy to go even faster. But BAAJA is also opposed by a handful of senators who have defined themselves by their support for aggressive climate policy, including Senators Ed Markey of Massachusetts and Bernie Sanders of Vermont. You could see this as a new-school climate hawk vs. old-school environmentalist fight, but the divide isn’t total. I find it interesting that Senator Tina Smith of Minnesota — an aggressive climate and clean energy advocate — says she’s “firmly opposed” to the bill because of what she worries it could mean for mining projects near the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness.
Lots more to say but we’ll leave it there for now.
