TEST TEST TEST

Products

The Dark Cloud Hanging Over COP31

alejandro admin

Description 2



This year’s United Nations climate conference was never going to produce the kind of headline-grabbing announcements that have defined some past summits. But it seems that negotiators at COP31, which is set to wrap up in Antalya, Turkey this weekend, are struggling to make even incremental progress.

One of the major outcomes of last year’s gathering was an agreement to “at least triple adaptation finance by 2035,” referring to grants, loans, and other assistance from developed to developing countries to help them adapt to climate changes they mostly did not cause. The goal was somewhat meaningless, however, because negotiators did not specify what the baseline annual number was — a tripling of what? Working that out was one of the major items on this year’s to-do list. Now it looks like everyone will be going home without an answer.

“It’s at a real impasse right now,” Rachel Cleetus, the program director for climate at the Union of Concerned Scientists, told me on Wednesday, adding that the European Union, specifically, was blocking an agreement. “The mood here is very very down in terms of what’s happening with finance.”

I have not yet had the chance to attend a COP, but my understanding is that the finance discussions are always quite tense. “More than usual?” I asked Cleetus, who goes each year.

She thought so. Now that the science is relatively clear that surpassing 1.5 degrees Celsius of warming is inevitable, she said, developing countries were expecting there to be more recognition of climate impacts and adaptation needs. “That’s the primary responsibility of richer, major polluting nations. But that just hasn’t happened.”

As of Thursday, the latest draft of the “cover decision” for the conference, a summary of what countries have agreed to, merely repeated the same “call for efforts to at least triple adaptation finance” in last year’s text. Rather than specify a target amount or baseline, it orders a technical report “identifying options for the baseline” to be considered at next year’s summit.

If the question was purely one of logic, without any politics, it would have an easy answer. In 2021, countries agreed to at least double adaptation finance from 2019 levels by 2025 — a goal of $40 billion. It takes a long time to track all of the public and private cash flows that count toward international finance goals, and the reporting tends to lag by two years, so we won’t know until next year whether countries achieved that $40 billion. Nonetheless, it would make sense for that to serve as the baseline for the updated goal, making the 2035 target $120 billion.

“That is the most logical reading,” Joe Thwaites, the international climate finance director for the Natural Resources Defense Council, told me. “But a lot of developed countries who are in the spotlight, given their tough political situations, are pushing back on the idea of writing something that would cleanly define that number.”

Thwaites said finance discussions were especially tense due to recent cuts to development aid that are "rattling a lot of countries.” Development assistance is expected to reach its lowest level since 2014 this year, according to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. It’s not just because of cuts from the U.S. — Germany, France, Japan, and the U.K. have also reduced international aid, which the OECD attributes to “heightened geopolitical tension, pressure to increase spending for defence and security and align public spending with domestic priorities, among others.” Countries are hesitant to commit to additional climate finance when they are cutting assistance across the board.

France and Germany also have upcoming elections, Thwaites pointed out, so they may be reluctant to make big announcements before seeing how those shake out. By contrast, the U.K. and Canada, with elections in the rearview, each recently made new, multi-year climate finance pledges.

“I think part of this is also just a reaction to the U.S. dropping out,” he added. “The Europeans are feeling frustrated that they’re being asked to fill a gap the U.S. has left behind, and they don’t think that that’s fair.”

Even the implied $120 billion goal would be nowhere near the actual expected cost for developing countries to adapt to climate change. The United Nations’ Environment Program estimates that developing countries will need more like $305 billion each year by 2035.

The disagreement isn’t just a back-and-forth about a number. In return for adaptation funding, developed countries want to see commitments from developing countries to do more to reduce emissions. This bargaining dynamic ends up excluding the most vulnerable countries from the conversation altogether, Thwaites said, because they don’t emit very much to begin with, leaving major economies like China and India — which, despite having two of the world’s largest economies by GDP, are still considered developing nations — to fight on their behalf.

“The most vulnerable who have done least to cause the problem and are hit first and worst by the impact, their needs aren’t front and center,” he told me. “And that, I think, is the great injustice of this.”

Popular

Latest News